As 2024 financial results start to trickle in over the month of February, the numbers for the two leading agency holding companies are out, and they tell a variety of stories. However, the bottom-line takeaway—which arguably has little to do with the actual results—is this: The big will continue to get bigger, no matter the price.
While the holding companies focus on scale, independent agencies are finding new opportunities to measure marketing impact for growth brands that may find themselves overlooked in the race for consolidation.
First, let’s look at the results. Publicis, having declared its period of transformation mostly behind it, ended 2024 up 8.3% in total revenue and up 5.8% in organic growth, hitting a healthy operating margin of 18%,. CEO Arthur Sadoun expressed confidence that the company would continue to significantly outperform the industry in 2025.
Omnicom ended the year up 6.8% in total revenue and 5.2% in organic growth, with an operating margin of 15.5%. However, their road ahead is complicated by the massive task of absorbing rival Interpublic Group (IPG), a merger expected to cause revenue to shrink by 3.7% in the short term
Scott Shamberg, CEO of Mile Marker, views these shifts through the lens of an independent shop focused on agility. A refugee of the holding company system himself, Shamberg sees the current landscape as one where the major players will essentially “eat each others’ lunch”.
“Those holding companies are going to continue just to cannibalize each other,” Shamberg said. “They’re going to keep pitching against each other and taking from each other in the hopes that business turns over every two years”.
While Omnicom plans to trim costs and eliminate duplicative overhead to save over $130 million, Shamberg warns that trying to grow by cutting is a double-edged sword. “I believe there’s got to be a balance between this race to the bottom on price… and the strategic direction and guidance they need when an agency can’t staff it properly with human expertise,” Shamberg noted.
The prevailing sentiment from industry analysts is that any client that isn’t a multinational advertiser spending at least half a billion in media is unlikely to get the attention they need from these expanding holding companies.
Steve Boehler, of consultancy Mercer Island Group, noted that the holding company focus is “crystal clear” on large, global clients. This leaves a significant portion of the market wondering where they fit in. “Most of their clients are not in that class. And so if I was most of their clients, I’d be wondering, ‘Why am I not hearing about myself?’” Boehler said.
This disruption creates a clear lane for independent agencies. As the giants focus on integration and “principal buying games” to satisfy Wall Street, independent agencies are better positioned to apply data-driven methodologies to measure marketing impact and ensure media investments translate into tangible business goals for mid-market and growth brand.
The upcoming integration of IPG into Omnicom is predicted to be a “horrific mess” over the next 12 months, with potential job losses estimated at 10,000 people across both entities. For clients, this often means the disruption of lost headcount and changes in day-to-day service.
While the holding companies battle for the top spot, the real opportunity lies in agility and service. As Shamberg suggests, the industry conundrum is maintaining expertise without succumbing to the “race to the bottom”.
For brands seeking transparency and dedicated attention, the choice between a holding company in turmoil and a focused independent partner has never been clearer.
Read the full article on Digiday.
Want to explore options for agency partnerships outside of holding companies? Let’s Connect.
A modern omnichannel media agency that delivers best-in-class tools with a transparent process and measurable outcomes. Ready to grow? Let’s talk
